FINDING · EVALUATION
In Censored Planet DNS measurements of 75 .gov and .mil domains on April 11, 2021, only 36.06% of measurements from China resolved correctly. Of the failures, 19.06% returned SERVFAIL codes caused by US-based nameservers geoblocking Chinese recursive resolvers—server-side access control, not GFW censorship—causing prior studies that did not account for geoblocking to systematically over-estimate DNS blocking in China.
From 2023-raman-advancing — Advancing the Art of Censorship Data Analysis · §3.3.2 · 2023 · Free and Open Communications on the Internet
Implications
- When estimating blocking rates to calibrate circumvention infrastructure deployment, filter out server-side geoblocking responses (SERVFAIL from origin nameservers) to avoid over-provisioning resources for apparent blocks that are actually access-control policies at the destination.
- Proxy selection logic should distinguish between DNS failures caused by the censor versus those caused by the destination server's own geofencing, since only the former requires circumvention.
Tags
Extracted by claude-sonnet-4-6 — review before relying.