FINDING · EVALUATION
Across three testers all on MTS, whitelist behavior varied by network segment in ways that could not be explained by protocol configuration alone; the operator has zero confirmed data for MegaFon, Beeline, or T2 under whitelist conditions. The open question of whether whitelist policy (site+IP list) is centrally issued by the Ministry of Digital Development while implementation differs per carrier remains unresolved, making cross-carrier generalization of any circumvention finding unreliable.
From 2026-amigocarra-bypassing-russian-federation-s — Bypassing the Russian Federation's mobile internet whitelists—we're stuck, looking for real-world experience · Issue body — questions 1 and 2 · 2026 · net4people/bbs
Implications
- Circumvention tool operators serving Russia should not extrapolate MTS test results to other carriers; instrument users to self-report carrier and collect per-carrier effectiveness data before making protocol recommendations.
- Engage the net4people/bbs community to crowdsource per-carrier whitelist CIDR lists, since centralized Ministry-issued lists may be implemented heterogeneously at each carrier's DPI layer.
Tags
Extracted by claude-sonnet-4-6 — review before relying.